News

 

As of July 11, a significant shift in the Chinese A-share market has taken place with the suspension of the stock borrowing and lending services. This action predominantly focuses on the traditional mechanisms of margin trading, commonly known in the West as short-selling. Although existing positions can be extended, they must be resolved by September 30. This has led to an increase in the margin requirements, thereby inflating the cost of short trades significantly. Recent data shows that as of July 12, the balance of borrowing in A-shares plummeted to approximately 31.76 billion RMB from a staggering 70.38 billion RMB at the start of 2023, indicating a drastic decrease in short-selling activity.

It is crucial to distinguish between the suspension of stock borrowing and the overall suspension of margin trading. Stock borrowing primarily enlarges the pool of available securities for lending, which consequently expands the scale of margin trading. Despite the suspension of stock borrowing, the overall margin trading operations remain unaffected, allowing the latter to continue. This development indicates a firm stance on regulating speculative activities within the market, an attempt to stabilize and nurture a more robust investment environment.

Advertisement

The halt on stock borrowing signifies a broader trend; it appears to be a protective measure for the A-share market, allowing long positions to breathe a little easier. Such legislative actions tend to stifle aggressive short-selling tactics and ultimately provide a more conducive atmosphere for bullish market sentiment to gather strength.

In addition to the suspension of stock borrowing, the regulatory authorities have rolled out stringent measures to govern algorithmic trading. As a consequence of these intensified oversight efforts, a noticeable decline in the scale of algorithmic trading has been observed. Reportedly, by the end of June, the number of high-frequency trading accounts had dwindled by over 20 percent, with behavior deemed as abnormal trading practices dropping nearly 60 percent within the past three months. This kind of market sophistication reflects renewed control intended to ward off reckless trading behaviors that could circumvent established financial protocols.

While quant trading hasn’t been entirely eliminated, the ongoing regulatory environment is clearly inducing a degree of normalization within this trading strategy. The significant decrease in active high-frequency trading accounts is an encouraging sign that regulatory measures are taking effect, leading to a healthier trading landscape.

From the suspension on stock borrowing to the governance of quantitative trading, the A-share market is making conscious efforts to showcase its commitment to a more stable trading environment. With increases in regulatory frameworks aiming at curtailing speculative actions and mitigating bearish market forces, a more extended bullish phase seems anticipated and awaits the right moment to flourish.

Despite these promising developments, A-shares continue to operate below the 3000-point mark. Indeed, since A-shares first breached the 3000-point threshold, there have been nearly 60 occasions where efforts have been made to defend this symbolic barrier. Thus, the question remains: when will the A-shares finally elevate themselves beyond the limits of 3000 points? Ultimately, this will depend on the integrity of the market’s investment ecosystem and the shifting dynamics of market liquidity.

Ample liquidity is pivotal for the stock market to fulfill efficiently its price-discovery function. A persistent state of liquidity scarcity diminishes the chances for even the best-managed companies to attain favorable valuations, leaving the market's inherent value undiscovered for far too long.

The stock market's extended hover around the 3000-point level can be attributed primarily to two prevailing factors: the substantial accumulation of trapped shares above the 3000-point threshold, representing vast pools of capital awaiting liberation; and the ongoing inadequacy of trading volume, which manifests starkly. A daily trading volume of 600 billion RMB may have sufficed a decade ago to meet the liquidity needs of most listed companies, but in today’s environment, this same volume falls woefully short in addressing the liquidity needs of the larger market capacity.

To enhance the investment ecosystem of the stock market, effective regulation at entry points into the market is essential, alongside expediting exit strategies to facilitate rigorous survival-of-the-fittest outcomes. However, tightening up the market exit criteria must go hand-in-hand with ensuring that retail investors receive proper compensation. Companies guilty of fraudulent activities and financial misconduct must face substantial punitive measures alongside their regulatory costs.

In a mere 17 years, the number of listed companies expanded from 1,400 to 5,400, while the total market capitalization surged from 20 trillion RMB to an impressive 70 trillion RMB. Nonetheless, it is regrettable that the market indices continue to languish around the 3000-point vicinity, and these indices fail to accurately mirror the price performance and intrinsic values of numerous companies.

In principle, A-shares are already considerably undervalued and rank among the least expensive in major stock markets globally. Nevertheless, the persistent stagnation is directly linked to the flawed investment ecosystem. If the investment ecosystem of A-shares were to improve, it wouldn’t be unduly complex for the market to rally. As liquidity improves significantly, so too would the stock market’s ability to generate returns and inspire investor confidence.

Having taken steps to suspend stock borrowing and regulate quantitative trading practices, the next critical area of focus must be to refine the processes surrounding market entry and exit while ensuring fair compensation for investors. Only through advancing the efficiency of a competitive market can we fundamentally shift the investment ecosystem prevailing within the stock market.